Commander vs Modern Article by Jeremy Blair
Commander can be a lot cheaper than many other forms of MTG because you only ever have to buy one copy of any card you want instead of the four you’d need for a more serious format. Plus, there are so many good cards that cost nothing to buy, you can often build decent Commander decks for less than £20. By far the best tool made is Spelltable, which is a free online service that lets you host games of Commander over webcam. Just put a webcam facing down at your desk, find a lobby to join, and get going.
When all packs/cards have been drafted, each player will build a 40-card deck from the cards they drafted and then play 1v1 games. What makes drafting an interesting experience is that not only do you have a limited card pool but you choose it one card at a time. So, it requires you to constantly be adapting and thinking on the fly in terms of deck-building. There’s the “cards I own” deck, which refers to decks that run only cards that their owners have in possession or can easily acquire.
I would have a hard time purchasing a Vesuva for $30 when they could formerly be obtained for around $4 to $5. However, they are really great cards next to a play set of Cloudposts and four Glimmerpost. Every Magic site hosts a column authored by a reputable financial advisor, and I often find myself reading over the advice. I am not that financial advisor, but rather a fan of collecting and lover of sweet investments. While I love reading financial tips and collecting tricks, the focus of the articles typically hones in on sanctioned tournament play. The Legacy, Standard, and newly announced Modern Constructed formats primarily drive the prices of Magic cards.
However, once Commander’s very fundamental limitation of one copy per card was removed, the floodgates continued to open ever wider. Furthermore, the format has reached a point where there are a massive number of functionally equivalent cards, so it’s a bit disingenuous to say it’s truly a Highlander format anymore. This is where combos edh a Rule 0 deck can give you a little bit more flavor to work with if you’re interested in expanding your deckbuilding horizons.
Rules
Devoid is a characteristic-defining keyword ability that states that a card is colorless, regardless of the colors in that card’s mana cost. That face’s color or colors then become the commander’s color identity for deck construction. This forces each card to act as a traditional double-faced card rather than a commander. While not a draft commander, Clara Oswald from the Doctor Who Commander deck fulfills the same function — allowing players to create a custom color identity for their deck.
The transforming planeswalkers from Magic Origins are perfect if you want to build around the Gatewatch, and most of Magic’s factions have obvious choices available for you. If you’re building around the Temur Frontier, for example, you’re basically just choosing between Surrak and Yasova Dragonclaw—the clan’s two leaders. So my friend has recently starting playing MTG and has bought some of the LOTR set. Stack Exchange network consists of 183 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Trader Tools lists both buylist and retail prices for every MTG card, going back a decade.
In Legacy for example, if a Red deck becomes overpowering, opponents can always add Blue Elemental Blast to their sideboard. A superfriends deck can conceivably remove the Sun and keep pumping. If the superfriends deck is overpowered, then the Sun would still help, but it would not be a decisive sideboard card. Some examples of Rule 0 possibilities include using banned cards and silver-bordered or acorn stamped cards, or adding a mechanic that does not appear on the card (but probably should).
What Is Commander Damage?
If you want to dip your toes in digitally before splashing out on a paper deck, Magic the Gathering Online supports Commander as well. You’ll still need to buy the cards (or rent them), but there’s less of a commitment to playing digitally than in-person or over webcam that may appeal to some people. Rule zero discussions are imperative for a good play experience. Otherwise, one person bringing a slow deck that wins through simple combat could be playing against a highly-optimised combo deck that wins as early as turn two – it isn’t fun for either player. Whether players agree with it or not, one of the key aspects of the Commander format is the idea of the ‘Social Contract’, which simply says “hey, let’s make sure everyone gets to have fun here”.
Draft is exciting because it’s more of a surprise on what you’ll get to pick from each new pack, contrasting with the more control you have building a deck in the Sealed format. It’s worth searching around for your local game stores or even some online trading communities for some of the more niche cards. When you finally complete your first Commander deck you’ll feel unstoppable. Just remember to at least let your friends think they’re going to win before flexing too much.
Commander’s biggest strength is it allows almost any card ever printed for the game. Putting that into Arena would require virtually every card ever made be programmed into it, complete with art, animations, sound effects, and rules interactions. Considering each set released on Arena comes with an update of around one gigabyte in size, imagine how big an update 20,000 cards over the last almost 30 years would be.
In fact, we think that, despite the size of the decks, learning how to play Commander is the best starting point for people looking to play MTG with more players. That being said, most people still follow the “constructed” deckbuilding ruleset, which is 60 card minimum, no more than 4 copies of any non-basic. Historic is a non-rotating, constructed format that exists only as a digital format. That said, cards from older sets are added to the card pool at WOTC’s discretion, and “digital-only” and rebalanced versions of paper cards are also featured. Two-Headed Giant allows you to play any format mentioned above with a partner.
In fact, I run it in over half of my decks and almost fainted when the price ran up into the $30 range. This list of cards might not hit every player, but many of these utility lands see a great deal of play in Commander and might see vast success in Modern. Many of the cards from this list have jumped 200% to 300% in the last couple of weeks and show little sign of slowing down. If you have a bunch of extra copies, you might want to sell them off or trade them for a great profit. If you have want a card from this list, you should act sooner than later or search for other options.
Is There Such a Thing as Casual Competitive?
In Sealed, you have the time and control to think clearly on what cards will be in your deck. This process can make it easier in refining your overall theme, but it’s harder because it involves more strategy and you do not have as much variety in choice of cards as in Draft. In a traditional draft you have a chance to swap cards in your deck between games using any cards you drafted. In Draft, each player opens one pack at a time, then every player picks one card from the booster pack they opened and passes the rest to the next person in the group to pick from that card pile, and so on.